From France to Germany, nationalist parties invoke Jewish safety while portraying Muslim immigration as a threat. Some Jewish leaders are challenging the message.
I keep coming across Facebook discussions that describe Muslims as a danger to Jews. Some refer to terrorist attacks. Others make much broader claims about Islam, as though hostility towards Jews were something Muslims had invented.
Reading these arguments from Karachi, I find myself returning to an uncomfortable piece of European history.
The worst persecution of Europe’s Jews did not come from Muslim societies. It happened in Europe itself. Christian-majority kingdoms expelled Jewish communities, and Nazi Germany later carried out the Holocaust.
That history is well documented. What interests me now is how some European nationalist parties have begun presenting themselves as defenders of Jews against Muslims.
A political conference in Jerusalem in March 2025 brought the contradiction into public view.
The Conference That Divided Jewish Leaders
Jordan Bardella, president of France’s National Rally, travelled to Jerusalem to attend a conference on antisemitism organised by Israel’s Diaspora Affairs Ministry.
His presence was politically significant.
National Rally grew out of the National Front, founded by Jean-Marie Le Pen in 1972. The party’s early history included links to figures associated with Vichy France. Its founder repeatedly made antisemitic statements and notoriously minimised the significance of Nazi gas chambers.
Under Marine Le Pen, the party tried to distance itself from that record. She expelled her father in 2015, and the organisation adopted the National Rally name in 2018.
By 2025, Bardella was attending an international gathering devoted to protecting Jews.
Not everyone welcomed him.
Jonathan Greenblatt, chief executive of the Anti-Defamation League, and French philosopher Bernard-Henri Lévy withdrew from the conference over the participation of European right-wing and far-right politicians.
Reuters reported the dispute on March 27, 2025.
The withdrawals challenged the assumption that supporting Israel automatically establishes a politician’s credentials as a defender of Jewish communities.
I found something else striking.
Jewish leaders were publicly disagreeing about which political allies they should accept. Yet the Facebook arguments I encounter often speak about Jews as though they share one political position.
The Jerusalem conference showed otherwise.
Europe Has a History That Cannot Be Blamed on Islam
England expelled its Jewish population in 1290. Spain ordered Jews to convert to Christianity or leave in 1492. During the First Crusade, Christian attackers massacred Jewish communities along the Rhine.
Christian anti-Judaism helped sustain centuries of discrimination. By the nineteenth century, racial nationalism had added new forms of hostility. Nazi Germany eventually organised the genocide of approximately six million Jews.
The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum documents how these different forms of antisemitism developed.
I have examined this history in an earlier article, Why Were Jews Persecuted in Europe?
There is no need to repeat every expulsion or massacre here.
Nor should medieval persecution, nineteenth-century nationalism and Nazism be treated as one continuous political movement. Their institutions and ideologies differed.
Jewish communities also suffered restrictions and periodic persecution under Muslim rulers. The historical record offers no basis for portraying Muslim societies as uniformly tolerant.
But Europe’s long history of anti-Jewish persecution makes the modern political transformation worth investigating.
Some movements that draw upon European nationalist traditions now argue that Muslim immigration poses the principal danger to Jewish life.
The question is whether their concern extends beyond the political usefulness of that argument.
France: National Rally Changes Its Message
Marine Le Pen began reshaping the National Front’s public image after taking control in 2011.
She increasingly portrayed Islamist extremism as a threat to French Jews. Following the Hamas-led attacks on Israel on October 7, 2023, the party became more outspoken in its support for Israel and opposition to antisemitism.
A May 2026 Carnegie Endowment analysis examines this transformation.
The strategy offered National Rally an opportunity to distance itself from the antisemitic reputation of its founder while strengthening its opposition to Islamism and immigration.
That does not prove every declaration of concern for Jewish citizens is insincere.
Political movements can change. Their supporters can reconsider old prejudices.
France’s own survey evidence shows why those possibilities must be taken seriously.
The National Consultative Commission on Human Rights, known as the CNCDH, published its 2025 racism and antisemitism report in June 2026.
Between 2022 and 2025, agreement with established antisemitic stereotypes fell by seven percentage points among National Rally sympathisers. Among supporters of the left-wing La France Insoumise, or LFI, the corresponding measure rose by ten points.
At the end of 2025, 48 percent of National Rally sympathisers and 47 percent of LFI sympathisers scored at least two on the report’s five-item antisemitism scale.
Those figures measure agreement with surveyed prejudices. They do not mean that these percentages of supporters commit antisemitic acts or share identical beliefs.
More severe scores remained somewhat more common among National Rally sympathisers.
The CNCDH’s original report provides the methodology and results.
The findings complicate a simple political story.
Antisemitic prejudice is not confined to Europe’s far right. Some attitudes among National Rally supporters have changed, while worrying trends have appeared elsewhere.
But a party’s changing public image still needs to be tested against its conduct.
France’s political realignment is real. Whether it amounts to a deeper commitment to equal treatment is a separate question.
Germany: The AfD’s Selective Defence of Jews
Germany’s Alternative for Germany, the AfD, has repeatedly connected antisemitism with immigration from Muslim-majority countries.
The party presents established political parties as unwilling to confront the problem. It claims to recognise a danger that mainstream politicians prefer to ignore.
A study by political researcher Claire Burchett provides unusually concrete evidence of how this message developed.
Published online in July 2025 in the journal Party Politics, Burchett’s research examined 430 AfD Facebook posts and 151 posts from Austria’s Freedom Party, the FPÖ.
The material covered 2017 to 2022. Researchers selected posts containing references to Jews, antisemitism or Israel.
One example came from January 2018.
An official AfD parliamentary Facebook post argued that the established parties’ refusal to recognise Islamic antisemitism allowed the danger to continue.
Another example appeared in 2019.
AfD politician Jörn König accused Germany’s political leadership of ignoring the perpetrators of antisemitism. His post linked the problem specifically to Muslim immigration.
Burchett found that the AfD used such arguments to present Jewish citizens as people abandoned by established political elites.
The party positioned itself as their defender.
But the research identified another side of that relationship.
When Jewish figures criticised the AfD or rejected its political arguments, the party’s treatment of them could change. Instead of appearing among the people it claimed to protect, Jewish critics could be portrayed as members of an opposing elite.
Burchett calls attention to this conditional political inclusion.
Her peer-reviewed study does not establish the private motives of every AfD politician. The sample also predates the latest German political developments.
It does, however, identify a documented pattern in the party’s public communication.
Jewish support becomes politically useful when it strengthens the argument against Muslim immigration. Jewish disagreement presents a problem.
Germany’s most prominent Jewish representative has openly challenged the party.
Josef Schuster, president of the Central Council of Jews in Germany, expressed alarm after the AfD’s strong performance in the 2025 federal election.
In an official statement, he criticised the party’s connections to right-wing extremism and neo-Nazism.
In a May 2025 interview with Süddeutsche Zeitung, Schuster warned that AfD participation in Germany’s federal government could raise serious questions about the future of Jewish life in the country.
The disagreement is substantial.
The AfD presents Muslim immigration as a major threat to Jewish security. The president of Germany’s principal Jewish representative body has warned about the AfD itself.
Neither position can simply be erased from the discussion.
I have previously examined the AfD’s broader political influence in Europe Built a Firewall Against the Far Right. The Politics Crossed It Anyway.
The dispute over Jewish safety reveals another part of that influence. It allows the party to frame immigration restrictions as protection for a historically persecuted minority.
Austria: Support for Israel Has Its Limits
Austria’s Freedom Party provides a related case, though its political language differs from the AfD’s.
The FPÖ has cultivated contacts with Israeli political figures and presented itself as an opponent of Islamist extremism.
Yet Burchett’s research found instances in which FPÖ politicians drew on familiar antisemitic themes when Israeli policies conflicted with their domestic political positions.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, for example, FPÖ politician Michael Schnedlitz shared a Facebook image in February 2021 portraying Austrian Chancellor Sebastian Kurz as a puppet controlled by Israel.
The post attacked Austria’s pandemic restrictions while presenting Israeli influence as a form of hidden control.
Burchett identified the imagery as overlapping with established antisemitic conspiracy themes.
The example is important because the party’s public support for Israel did not prevent one of its politicians from using imagery associated with antisemitic stereotypes.
Austria’s Jewish leadership has also expressed concern about the FPÖ.
After the party won the September 2024 parliamentary election, Oskar Deutsch, president of Vienna’s Jewish community, criticised its connections to German nationalist student fraternities with histories linked to Nazism.
He said the election victory made many Jewish Austrians feel threatened.
Austria’s public broadcaster ORF reported his comments on October 1, 2024. The FPÖ rejected the accusations concerning its associations.
The conflict illustrates why public support for Israel cannot serve as the only measure of a party’s attitude towards Jewish citizens.
A politician’s position on Israeli foreign policy and their treatment of Jewish communities at home are different matters.
Antisemitism Among Muslims Cannot Be Ignored
I would make a serious mistake if I used these political contradictions to dismiss antisemitism among Muslims.
It exists.
The Hamas-led attacks on October 7, 2023, were followed by a sharp increase in reported antisemitic incidents across several European countries.
Jewish people have faced threats and abuse connected to extremist interpretations of Islam. Conspiracy theories about Jewish power also circulate in Muslim communities.
I have encountered such material myself.
A forwarded video in a WhatsApp group or an angry Facebook comment can turn criticism of Israel into an accusation against Jews everywhere.
I reject that reasoning. A government’s actions do not establish the guilt of people who share a religion or ancestry.
The British figures offer a useful way to examine the wider picture.
The Community Security Trust, which monitors antisemitism in the United Kingdom, recorded 3,700 antisemitic incidents in 2025. It was the organisation’s second-highest annual total.
Of those incidents, 253 showed explicit far-right ideology. Another 39 contained evidence of radical Islamist ideology.
Twenty-eight incidents combined extreme right-wing ideology with hostility towards both Jews and Muslims.
The figures come from the CST’s 2025 Antisemitic Incidents Report.
The categories require careful interpretation.
CST records reported incidents that meet its definition of antisemitism, including some incidents that are not criminal offences. Its ideological classifications depend on evidence visible in individual cases.
The figures do not identify the political or religious beliefs of every perpetrator.
We therefore cannot compare 253 with 39 and conclude that one entire political or religious population is a particular number of times more antisemitic than another.
What the figures do establish is that antisemitic hostility emerges through different ideological traditions.
They also document something often overlooked in arguments portraying Jews and Muslims as natural enemies.
Some extremists express hostility towards both communities.
France’s 2025 Hate Figures Complicate the Picture
France’s Interior Ministry recorded 1,320 antisemitic acts in 2025, a decline of 16 percent from the previous year.
The number remained historically high.
The ministry also recorded 326 anti-Muslim acts, an increase of 88 percent compared with 2024.
These are official monitoring figures, though the ministry cautions that its reporting system is intended to identify trends rather than serve as a complete statistical measure of victimisation.
The Interior Ministry published the figures in February 2026.
Jewish and Muslim communities differ greatly in population size. Reporting patterns may also differ, which makes direct comparisons of raw totals misleading.
Still, the figures leave little room for denying either problem.
France has a serious antisemitism problem. Anti-Muslim hostility also increased sharply during 2025.
A movement that presents itself as defending religious minorities should be judged by how it responds to both.
That does not require it to support unrestricted immigration. Immigration policy involves legitimate questions about public administration and security.
But a person who has committed no offence should not become a suspect merely because of their religion.
When Does Jewish Safety Become a Political Argument Against Muslims?
Political parties have always used public concerns to win support. Security is particularly powerful because voters often respond to threats more quickly than to promises.
A party that describes Muslim immigration as the main source of antisemitism can make two arguments at once.
It can claim to defend Jewish citizens while accusing its political opponents of exposing those citizens to danger through immigration policy.
The argument becomes more effective when the party’s own historical connections to antisemitism receive less attention.
But the evidence does not support treating every right-wing party as identical.
Researchers examining European radical-right movements have found considerable differences in their positions towards Israel and Jews.
Some parties have changed their rhetoric substantially. Others remain openly hostile to Jews. A party’s position may also shift according to the political issue under discussion.
The AfD and FPÖ studies identify specific patterns in particular periods. They do not prove that every European nationalist leader follows a single plan.
What concerns me is the political incentive behind selective protection.
If Jewish communities are valued mainly because their suffering can justify restrictions against Muslims, their protection may depend on their willingness to support that argument.
When Jewish leaders object, the disagreement exposes the limits of the alliance.
A Question Europe Should Ask Its Political Parties
I began with Facebook because the arguments I encounter there often reduce a long history to a confrontation between two religions.
Jews become one political community. Muslims become another. Violence committed by particular people is assigned to millions who had nothing to do with it.
The historical record is more demanding.
European Jews suffered persecution from Christian authorities and later from nationalist movements. Muslim rulers also persecuted Jewish communities at different times. Neither history can be used to assign inherited guilt to people living today. I explored that question in Not in My Name: Why Must Jews Answer for Israel and Muslims Answer for Terrorism?
Jewish historians and organisations have never been silent about Europe’s role in their persecution. Much of what we know about that history comes from their work.
The more important question concerns politicians who now claim to defend Jewish citizens.
Do they confront antisemitic ideas among their own supporters? Do they respect Jewish organisations that disagree with them? And do their policies protect Muslim citizens from religious discrimination?
These questions require evidence about political conduct, not declarations of friendship.
The Jerusalem conference remains an instructive example.
Bardella attended and publicly opposed antisemitism. Greenblatt and Lévy objected to the participation of far-right politicians.
Both events happened at the same conference.
For me, the disagreement says more about contemporary European politics than another Facebook argument about whether Jews and Muslims can ever live together.
The people whose safety politicians invoke are not obliged to accept the politicians claiming to protect them.

One thought on “Europe’s Far Right Says It Protects Jews. Why Do Jewish Leaders Distrust It?”