Europe is building plans to make housing more affordable. But for tenants trapped in unsuitable homes, the problem is not always the rent they pay. Sometimes it is the cost of moving out.
A leaking ceiling is usually a reason to call the landlord. If the repair never comes, a tenant might consider moving.
But what if the next apartment costs €300 more each month? What if the landlord wants two months’ rent as a deposit, and the available homes are an hour farther from work?
The tenant may stay. Nothing in that decision necessarily means the apartment is acceptable. Leaving may simply cost too much.
I have been following Europe’s housing problems through reports on Germany and Ireland. Much of the debate concerns rising rents and the shortage of affordable homes. I keep returning to a less visible consequence: a housing shortage can make it harder for tenants to walk away from a rental arrangement that no longer works.
The Numbers Tell Only Part of the Story
Eurostat’s Housing in Europe 2025 report shows that rents across the European Union increased by 25% between 2010 and 2024. House prices rose by 53%.
These are nominal increases. Consumer prices rose by 39% over the same period, so the EU-wide rent index increased less than general inflation. That does not mean every renter found housing more affordable.
Ireland recorded a 108% rise in rents between 2010 and 2024. Estonia’s increase reached 208%. Greece, by contrast, recorded a decline of 16%.
A European average conceals remarkably different rental markets. It also tells us little about the price of a newly advertised apartment in a particular city. A tenant who has lived in the same property for years may face a very different price from someone searching for a new home. The difference matters when the first tenant considers moving.
Why Leaving Can Be More Expensive Than Staying
Imagine a family renting an apartment for €900 a month. Their landlord has not addressed a persistent maintenance problem. They find another suitable apartment, but the advertised rent is €1,200.
Moving would increase their annual rent by €3,600. They would also need money for the deposit and the move itself. These figures are illustrative, not a survey of European rents.
The family might decide to remain in the old apartment while pursuing a repair complaint. From the outside, that decision could look like acceptance. In reality, it may reflect a shortage of affordable alternatives.
Economists regard the available alternative to an agreement as an important part of bargaining power. A tenant who can move easily has more freedom to reject unreasonable conditions. Someone facing a substantial financial penalty for leaving has fewer practical options.
Landlords face constraints too. They must maintain properties, meet financing obligations and comply with national tenancy laws. An empty apartment can mean lost income. But the costs of a failed rental relationship are not always equal. For a landlord, the immediate problem may be finding another tenant. For a renter, it can mean finding another home.
The Pressure Falls Unevenly
According to Eurostat, EU households spent an average of 19% of their disposable income on housing in 2024. Among people whose income was below 60% of the national median, the average share was 37%.
The figures include housing costs beyond rent. They also cover different types of households, including homeowners. Still, they reveal how little financial room some households have.
A person spending a large share of income on housing may struggle to save for another deposit. Moving farther away might reduce rent but increase transport costs. Parents must also consider schools and childcare. Someone who works irregular hours may have limited time to attend property viewings.
Eurostat’s 2026 figures show that 9.6% of people living in EU cities faced housing-cost overburden in 2025, compared with 5.6% in rural areas. The measure covers people in households whose housing costs exceed 40% of disposable income, after accounting for housing allowances.
The EU-wide rate has fallen in recent years, which is encouraging. Yet the improvement does not remove severe pressure in particular cities or among vulnerable households. A tenant does not search for an apartment across the European Union. The search happens in a local market, often within a limited distance from work or family.
Some Applicants Face Another Obstacle
Finding a new home is not only a question of affordability. In July 2025, Eurostat published findings on perceived discrimination when people searched for housing.
In its 2024 survey, 5.9% of EU residents aged 16 and over reported feeling discriminated against during a housing search. Among people at risk of poverty or social exclusion, the figure reached 10.1%. For those not at risk, it was 4.7%.
These were self-reported experiences. The survey did not establish that every incident amounted to unlawful discrimination. The difference is still difficult to ignore.
People already facing financial hardship were more likely to report another barrier to finding accommodation. For someone considering whether to leave an existing tenancy, the possibility of being rejected repeatedly can make the decision harder. A tenant may have the legal right to end a rental agreement. That right offers little help if the next landlord will not accept the application.
A Landlord Does Not Have to Break the Law for a Tenant to Feel Trapped
The word exploitation carries serious implications. We should use it carefully.
Not every neglected repair amounts to deliberate misconduct. Not every rent increase is unlawful. A disagreement over maintenance does not automatically make a landlord abusive. National tenancy laws differ, and the details of each dispute matter.
But a tenant can remain in an unsatisfactory home without any proven legal violation. The apartment may be too small for a growing family. It may be far from work, or the heating may be expensive. The tenant might simply want to live somewhere else.
Moving would normally provide a way out. When suitable alternatives are unaffordable, the tenant loses some of that flexibility.
I explored a more serious form of housing dependence in my earlier article, Sex for Rent in Germany. That investigation examined reported cases involving sexual conditions attached to accommodation. I also examined the question of consent in When Saying No Means Homelessness.
Such conduct should not be confused with ordinary rental disputes. Nor do the available reports establish how widespread it is. The broader economic issue is different: a shortage of alternatives can make tenants more dependent on their existing housing arrangements, even when nobody has committed an offence.
Europe Has Recognised the Shortage. What About the Cost of Leaving?
In September 2026, the European Commission issued a recommendation on housing affordability and supply in areas under housing stress.
The Commission recognised that housing difficulties can restrict people’s ability to move for work or education. It also acknowledged that the problem varies between regions.
The proposed policy direction includes increasing housing supply and making better use of existing buildings. These are sensible priorities.
A market with more suitable homes may give tenants greater choice. Renovating unused properties or converting suitable buildings could help in places where demand exceeds supply. Yet construction takes time, and additional homes may not be affordable to the households that need them most.
European rental regulation remains largely a national matter. Tenants in Germany, Ireland and other EU countries operate under different legal systems. The European Commission cannot resolve every local tenancy dispute through a single housing recommendation. National governments and local authorities must decide how to combine new supply with effective tenant protection.
What Should Governments Measure?
Policymakers already collect substantial information about rents and housing-cost burdens. Those indicators are useful, but they do not directly measure how easily a tenant can leave an unsuitable property.
I would like to see more attention paid to the practical cost of moving. How much does a comparable apartment cost for someone entering the market today? How much money must a household find before moving? How long does the search take?
And how many people remain in unsuitable homes because they cannot afford an alternative?
These are questions for further research, not statistics I can supply from the available Eurostat data. They could help explain why some households experience serious housing difficulties even when broad affordability indicators improve.
Better information would also help policymakers distinguish between a shortage of homes and a shortage of homes people can actually afford to occupy. The two problems overlap, but they are not identical.
A Home Should Not Become a Financial Trap
A rental agreement is supposed to give a tenant a place to live in exchange for payment, subject to the rights and obligations set out in law. Neither party can expect a relationship without disagreements.
A landlord may need to recover legitimate costs. A tenant may demand repairs or challenge a charge. The legal system provides ways to handle those disputes, although the procedures vary between countries.
What concerns me is the situation in which a tenant has a reasonable wish to leave but cannot afford to act on it.
The European Commission is right to focus on increasing the supply of suitable housing. More affordable alternatives could reduce that pressure.
But the success of housing policy should not be judged only by the number of apartments built or the movement of an average rent index. A family might have a roof over its head and still have almost no realistic choice about where to live.
We count the cost of staying. We should also start counting the cost of leaving.
