A professional woman stands beside a reflective glass wall with London's Parliament buildings visible in the distance

When Did Being Muslim Become an Identity Others Assign?

Why do some people see a person’s religion before their profession, beliefs or achievements? A reader’s question led me to an unexpected study of Christians mistaken for Muslims.

A reader recently told me about a Muslim councillor who wanted people to recognise her political work before noticing her religion.

Nicholas B. Taylor was commenting on my article about whether religious statistics can measure genuine faith.

He described a debate at University College London in which a Muslim councillor reportedly said that she was a politician who happened to be Muslim. Yet people tended to see her religion first.

Nicholas questioned her choice of words. He also asked something that caught my attention.

When did Muslim become an ethnicity?

I have thought about that question since reading his comment.

Muslim is not an ethnicity. Islam is a religion followed by people from many ethnic backgrounds. But Nicholas had noticed how easily religious identity can become a label that other people assign.

Sometimes they do not even get the religion right.

A Muslim Politician Who Wants to Be Seen Differently

I have not been able to locate the original debate recording or verify the councillor’s identity. I am therefore relying on Nicholas’s description.

He understood her reported words as suggesting that being Muslim was almost incidental to her identity.

I read them differently.

A person can take religion seriously without wanting it to determine how others judge every part of their life.

Consider a local councillor discussing housing policy.

She may be a practising Muslim. She may also have spent years studying the shortage of affordable homes and the problems facing tenants.

Why should her religious identity tell us more about her housing proposals than the proposals themselves?

I would want to know what she intends to do.

Her faith may influence her thinking, just as another politician’s Christian beliefs or secular convictions may influence theirs. But I cannot work out someone’s political programme from a religious label.

Nicholas is right to ask what people mean when they describe themselves as Muslim.

I would also ask why other people sometimes treat that description as the most important fact about them.

The Christians Who Were Mistaken for Muslims

An academic study published in 2023 provides a revealing example.

Alistair Hunter and Fiona McCallum Guiney, researchers at the University of St Andrews, examined the experiences of Christians of Middle Eastern heritage living in Britain.

Their paper appeared in the Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies under the title Misrecognised as Muslim: The Racialisation of Christians of Middle Eastern Heritage in the UK.

The researchers examined how people who belonged to Christian communities could nevertheless be perceived as Muslim because of their background or appearance.

Some participants described experiences in which strangers made incorrect assumptions about their religion.

I found this more revealing than an argument about how sincerely someone practises a faith.

These were Christians. Their religious identity was not especially ambiguous in the context of their own communities.

Yet other people looked at their Middle Eastern heritage and assumed they must be Muslims.

The study does not establish how frequently this happens across Britain. It is qualitative research, concerned with people’s experiences rather than estimating a national percentage.

Its value lies in showing the process.

A stranger sees what they believe to be a Middle Eastern appearance. They associate that appearance with Islam.

The person standing before them may be Christian, but that possibility has already been overlooked.

You can read the original research published through the University of St Andrews.

How Religion Becomes Racialised

Researchers call this process racialisation.

The term describes how people come to be treated as members of a supposedly fixed group because of characteristics such as appearance or ancestry.

Religion can become entangled with those assumptions.

A man may have an Arabic name and belong to a Christian family. Someone unfamiliar with the region might assume he is Muslim.

Another person may come from a Muslim family but no longer practise Islam. Strangers may continue to identify that person as Muslim.

I have encountered broad claims about what Muslims supposedly think, as though people from different countries shared one political mind.

They do not.

Muslims may share religious commitments, but they disagree about politics. Their relationships with religious institutions also vary.

The distinction extends beyond Islam.

In an earlier article about Christianity and European identity, I examined how people can remain attached to Christian heritage without regularly attending church.

Religious belonging does not always tell us how someone practises their faith.

The additional problem is that outsiders may assign a religious identity without asking the individual at all.

What Britain’s Census Can Tell Us

The Office for National Statistics makes a useful distinction in its explanation of the 2021 census of England and Wales.

The census included a voluntary question about religion.

According to the ONS, the question measured religious affiliation. Respondents could identify with a religion even if they did not practise it or believe its teachings.

Ethnicity was recorded separately.

The figures show that 6.5% of people in England and Wales identified as Muslim in 2021, compared with 4.9% in 2011.

Those percentages describe religious affiliation.

They cannot tell us how devout the respondents were. Nor can they establish the political views of people who selected the Muslim category.

I do not see a problem with collecting this information.

Reliable population data helps researchers understand demographic change. It can also help public institutions examine whether particular communities experience unequal treatment.

The question is how we interpret the figures.

A census records the identity people report about themselves.

It does not give strangers permission to decide what an individual believes.

Ramla Ali: When Religion Is Relevant to a Story

Nicholas also mentioned boxer Ramla Ali.

He questioned why the BBC described her as a Muslim athlete when reporting her achievements.

I checked the BBC Sport profile published on 15 August 2022.

The article described Ali’s journey from Somalia to Britain and her success in boxing. It also identified her as the first Muslim boxer to win an English amateur title.

But the report went further than Nicholas suggested.

Ali spoke about her own religious beliefs. She explained that her faith mattered to her and discussed plans to perform Umrah during a visit to Saudi Arabia.

Her Muslim identity also formed part of the story of how she pursued boxing while navigating family expectations.

I would therefore hesitate to criticise the BBC for mentioning her religion.

The reporter had information from Ali herself. Her faith was relevant to the circumstances being described.

Of course, her achievements in boxing deserve recognition independently of her religious identity.

But leaving out a significant part of her experience would not necessarily produce a more accurate portrait.

The question is whether journalists establish the relevance of someone’s religion before making it part of the story.

In Ali’s case, the BBC provided that context.

Nicholas’s broader concern remains valid. In this particular example, however, the reporting is more careful than his comment suggests.

When the Label Affects Someone’s Life

Religious assumptions can have consequences beyond newspaper descriptions.

In October 2024, the European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights published its report Being Muslim in the EU.

The findings came from a 2022 survey involving nearly 10,000 Muslim respondents in 13 EU countries.

Among those surveyed, 47% reported experiencing racial discrimination in the preceding five years.

The agency defined racial discrimination broadly, covering grounds that included skin colour, ethnic or immigrant background, and religion.

The report also found that 39% had experienced racial discrimination when looking for work during that five-year period.

These are findings about the surveyed respondents in the countries covered. They should not be presented as a measurement of every Muslim living in Europe.

Even with that limitation, the figures deserve attention.

The report describes experiences involving employment and housing. It also examines the additional difficulties faced by some women who wear religious clothing.

We should distinguish between someone choosing to express a religious identity and someone else using that identity as a reason to exclude them.

A Muslim woman may wear a headscarf because of her own convictions.

An employer who assumes that she will not fit into a workplace because of that headscarf is making a different kind of decision.

One concerns her religious practice.

The other concerns how someone with power judges her.

A Similar Problem With Jews and Christians

I would not limit this discussion to Muslims.

People sometimes make political assumptions about Christians because they identify with Christianity.

A person who attends church may have views on immigration that differ considerably from those of another Christian in the same country.

Jewish people can also face demands to explain or defend the actions of Israel’s government, regardless of their own position.

I examined that problem in an earlier article, Why Must Jews Answer for Israel and Muslims Answer for Terrorism?

The argument is not that religion has no influence on political behaviour.

Of course it can.

Religious leaders sometimes campaign on public issues. Individuals may draw on faith when deciding how to vote.

But we still need evidence of what a particular person believes or supports.

I do not want anyone deciding my political opinions merely because I am Muslim.

I would extend the same courtesy to someone who identifies as Christian or Jewish.

If a person makes a political claim, we can examine it.

We need not invent their position from their background.

What Nicholas’s Question Helped Me Understand

Nicholas began with an interest in how religious identity passes from parents to children.

That remains an important subject for researchers.

But his question about whether Muslim has become an ethnicity led me toward a different problem.

What happens when society continues to identify someone through religion, even when the individual has offered no information about their beliefs?

The Middle Eastern Christians in the British study offer a particularly clear example.

Their experience was not simply about having a religious identity.

It was about other people getting that identity wrong.

I still think Nicholas raises a fair question about how we describe religious belonging. I disagree with his reading of the BBC’s treatment of Ramla Ali, but that does not weaken his wider concern.

The councillor he described reportedly wanted people to recognise her political work without overlooking everything else about her.

That seems reasonable to me.

I would judge a politician by what she proposes and what she does in office. If her religion influences those decisions, I can examine that influence.

But her name or family background cannot provide the answer.

The researchers in Britain found Christians whom strangers had mistaken for Muslims.

I keep returning to that finding.

The individuals knew their own religion. The strangers believed they knew it too.

Only one side had bothered to live with the answer.

2 thoughts on “When Did Being Muslim Become an Identity Others Assign?”

Leave a Reply